| Name | Degree | Years on Court | Biographical Links |
| Benjamin Robbins Curtis | LLB 1832 | 1851-1857 | Oyez | Cornell | The Supreme Court of the United States: A Series of Biographical Sketches (HeinOnline) | Wikipedia |
| Horace Gray | LLB 1849 | 1882-1902 | Oyez | Cornell | The Supreme Court of the United States: a Series of Biographical Sketches (HeinOnline) | Wikipedia |
| Melville Weston Fuller, Chief Justice | Attended 1855 | 1888-1910 | Oyez | Cornell | The Supreme Court of the United States: a Series of Biographical Sketches (HeinOnline) | Wikipedia |
| Henry Billings Brown | LLB 1859 | 1891-1906 | Oyez | Cornell | The Supreme Court of the United States: a Series of Biographical Sketches (HeinOnline) | Wikipedia |
| Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr. | LLB 1866 | 1902-1932 | Oyez | Cornell | Wikipedia |
| William Henry Moody | LLB 1877 | 1906-1910 | Oyez | Cornell | Wikipedia |
| Louis Dembitz Brandeis | LLB 1877 | 1916-1939 | Oyez | Cornell | Findlaw |Wikipedia |
| Edward Terry Sanford | LLB 1889 | 1923-1930 | Oyez | Cornell | Wikipedia |
| Felix Frankfurter | LLB 1906 | 1939-1962 | Oyez | Cornell | Wikipedia |
| Harold Hitz Burton | LLB 1912 | 1945-1958 | Oyez | Cornell | Wikipedia |
| William J. Brennan, Jr. | LLB 1931 | 1956-1990 | Oyez | Cornell | Wikipedia |
| Harry A. Blackmun | LLB 1932 | 1970-1994 | Oyez | Cornell | Wikipedia |
| Lewis F. Powell, Jr. | LLM 1932 | 1972-1987 | Oyez | Cornell | Wikipedia |
| Ruth Bader Ginsburg | Attended 1956-58 | 1993- | U.S. Supreme Court | Women's Legal History Biography Project | Oyez | Cornell | Findlaw |Wikipedia |
| Antonin Scalia | LLB 1960 | 1986- | U.S. Supreme Court | Oyez | Cornell | Findlaw |Wikipedia |
| Anthony M. Kennedy | LLB 1961 | 1988- | U.S. Supreme Court | Oyez | Cornell | Findlaw |Wikipedia |
| Stephen G. Breyer | LLB 1964 | 1994- | U.S. Supreme Court | Oyez | Cornell | Findlaw |Wikipedia |
| David H. Souter | LLB 1966 | 1990-2009 | U.S. Supreme Court | Oyez | Cornell | Findlaw |Wikipedia |
| John G. Roberts, Jr., Chief Justice | JD 1979 | 2005- | U.S. Supreme Court | Oyez | Cornell | Findlaw |Wikipedia |
| Elena Kagan | JD 1986 | 2010- | U.S. Supreme Court | Oyez | Wikipedia |