The Petrie-Flom Center for Health Law Policy, Biotechnology, and Bioethics at Harvard Law School

Moral Biology: What, (if anything), Can the Mind Sciences Teach Us about Law and Morality?

April 2010

In the "Introductory Lectures on Psychoanalysis," Sigmund Freud famously suggested that humanity would suffer three great blows at the hand of science:

"The first was when they learnt that our earth was not the center of the universe but only a tiny fragment of a cosmic system of scarcely imaginable vastness. This is associated in our minds with the name of Copernicus, though something similar had already been asserted by Alexandrian science. The second blow fell when biological research destroyed man’s supposedly privileged place in creation and proved his descent from the animal kingdom and his ineradicable animal nature. This revaluation has been accomplished in our own days by Darwin, Wallace and their predecessors, though not without the most violent contemporary opposition. But human megalomania will have suffered its third and most wounding blow from the psychological research of the present time which seeks to prove to the ego that it is not even master in its own house, but must content itself with scanty information of what is going on un­consciously in the mind."

Today, many would disagree that psychoanalysis delivered that last blow, but research on evolutionary biology and the mind sciences threatens to provide it with force.  This is the subject of this conference which brought together academics from law, economics, neuroscience, psychology, philosophy, and economics.  We explored the question by focusing on 5 particular issues: Responsibility, Punishment, Addiction, Cooperation, and Racism.

Conference Programs and Panel Descriptions

 

Introduction from Dean Martha Minow

 

Panel Recordings

What Does Moral Biology Have to Say about Responsibility and Judgment?

Dan Brock
Introduction
Amanda Pustilnik
Moral Biology and Responsiblitiy: All or Nothing?
Nita Farahany
Neuroscience and Freedom
Stephen Morse
Morality and Biology: The Inevitable Interaction
Don Braman
Some Realism about Punishment Naturalism
 
Q&A Discussion1
Q&A Discussion 2

The Mind Sciences and Punishment

Jon Hanson
Introduction
Mark Alicke
Social Sanction and Legal Sanction:  A Culpable
Control Perspective
Fiery Cushman
Two Functions of Morality
Avani Sood
Psychological Underpinnings for Support for Terror in the Context of Interrogation
Kurt Gray
Escaping Blame: Moral Typecasting and the Power of Victimhood
 

Q&A Discussion 1
Q&A Discussion 2

Addiction-Intervention Paradigm

Stephen Morse
Introduction
Steven Hyman
Neuroscience of Addiction
Rita Goldstein
Lessons from Neuroimaging and Neuropsychology in Drug Addiction
Richard Bonnie
So What? Advances in Neurobiology of Addiction and Drug Policy
Stephen Morse
Summary
 
Q&A Discussion


Panel Debate:

Moral Biology? What Can the Mind Sciences Teach Us about
Law and Morality?


I. Glenn Cohen, Joshua Greene, William FitzPatrick
Walter Sinnot-Armstrong, Adina Roskies, Thomas Scanlon
 


Biology and Cooperation

Panelists:
Yochai Benkler
Audio Only
Oliver Goodenough
David Rand
Kevin McCabe
 

The Mind Sciences and Racism

Panelists:
Jon Hanson
Audio Only
Nilanjana Dasgupta
Nalini Ambady
Valerie Purdie-Vaughns
Curtis Hardin
 

 

Events & Webcasts